Prop 8 is opposed by the American Nurses Association / California, California Medical Association, emergency room doctors and patient advocates because it would jeopardize access to care for the most vulnerable patients in California – dialysis patients who need frequent treatment to survive. The measure sets severely low limits on what insurance companies pay for dialysis care. These limits do not account for the actual cost for providing care and would force many clinics to cut back services or even close.
Dialysis patients cannot survive without regular treatments three days a week, four hours at a time. With demand for dialysis growing at about five percent a year in California, patients already have difficulty finding appointment times convenient and close to home. Prop 8 would result in clinic closures and cutbacks in services, forcing patients to travel long distances or end up in overcrowded hospital emergency rooms to receive care. Research shows that missing even one dialysis appointment increases the risk of death for dialysis patients by 30%.Learn More
The American Nurses Association / California, California Medical Association, American College of Emergency Physicians, California chapter, patient advocates and others all oppose Prop 8 because it is dangerous for dialysis patients.Learn More
Proposition 8 narrowly defines what insurance companies are required to reimburse dialysis clinics for patient care. Prop 8’s definition of “patient care services costs” prohibits clinics from billing insurance companies for critical staff and necessary services required by federal regulators for operating a clinic. Prop 8 excludes:
As dialysis clinics shut down, options for treatment would be severely limited. This would force patients to seek regular treatment or treatment for complications in more expensive hospital emergency rooms, meaning more ER and hospital overcrowding, and potentially hundreds of millions of dollars in higher costs for Medi-Cal and Medicare to treat dialysis patients – and higher costs for taxpayers.Learn More
Prop 8 is being funded by United Healthcare Workers West (UHW) union as part of an attempt to pressure dialysis clinics to unionize workers.
Since 2012 UHW has spent $35 million in California and other states on more than 20 punitive state and local ballot measures in an attempt to force healthcare providers to accept their union organizing and contract demandsLearn More